I'm not clear on what you are trying to do, but it sounds like you might not be using the Value component correctly. The Value component is best understood as a "sample and hold" device that passes through a signal when the control input is TRUE, then will hold (memorize/freeze, etc) the output when the control input goes FALSE.
It sounds like you want to either use a switch (binary or selected with a number) or maybe put the values into an array.
